home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1549>
- <title>
- Nov. 07, 1994: Music:Singing to a Silent Harp
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Nov. 07, 1994 Mad as Hell
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- ARTS & MEDIA/MUSIC, Page 87
- Singing to a Silent Harp
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> Dolores O'Riordan, Sinead O'Connor and Katell Keineg carry on
- the great Irish tradition of glorious voices
- </p>
- <p>By Christopher John Farley
- </p>
- <p> From rebellions to potato famines, Ireland is a place with a
- long history of hardship and an equally long tradition of singing
- about it. As a defining cultural activity, singing is for the
- Irish what baseball is for Americans or chess is for the Russians.
- Ireland's national symbol is a harp, the instrument used to
- accompany a singer, and the national genius, James Joyce, was
- probably more vain about his voice than his prose style.
- </p>
- <p> Three singers who have among the most glorious voices in pop
- music are carrying on the Irish vocal tradition. Dolores O'Riordan,
- lead singer of the rock band the Cranberries, the ever feisty
- Sinead O'Connor and newcomer Katell Keineg (born in Celtic Brittany,
- she lives in Dublin) have distinct personalities, to be sure,
- but they all have a flair for emotional and vocal dramatics--a typical Celtic intensity--and they all partake of that
- peculiarly Irish mix of melancholy, anger and romance. Moreover,
- they all share a feminist perspective, singing songs about women
- taking control of their lives.
- </p>
- <p> The Cranberries' debut album, Everybody Else Is Doing It, So
- Why Can't We?, which sold 2 million copies after its release
- last year, was wonderfully assured; their new CD, No Need to
- Argue, shows even more range and promise. The new record begins
- with a personal statement from O'Riordan, a genial midtempo
- song called Ode to My Family. "We were raised/ to see life as
- fun and take it if we can," she sings. The album overflows with
- honeyed pop melodies, in particular the introspective Twenty-One
- and the aching Daffodil Lament. On the latter, O'Riordan shows
- off her voice, yelping one moment, going supple and suggestive
- the next, and then suddenly becoming unnervingly direct: "I
- have decided to leave you forever/I have decided to start things
- from here."
- </p>
- <p> On their debut, the Cranberries focused on songs that were dreamy
- and tender. Their new CD shows they can handle tougher rock--Zombie, a track that deals with violence in Northern Ireland,
- swaggers along with snarling guitar power chords. "This album
- is a bit more experimental," says O'Riordan, 23. "And a bit
- more outspoken."
- </p>
- <p> O'Connor has already gone way past outspoken. Since releasing
- her first album in 1987, she has ripped up a picture of the
- Pope on national TV, engaged in a war of words with Frank Sinatra
- and accused her mother of stomping on her belly to try to burst
- her uterus. But her controversies do seem to make her music
- all the more varied and pungent, and no one can dispute that
- O'Connor has an astonishing voice. Her new album, Universal
- Mother, starts not a little acrimoniously with the grinding,
- pulsating Fire on Babylon, in which the singer again attacks
- her late mother. "She took my father from my life/ took my sister
- and brothers, oh," O'Connor howls. She also bares her fangs
- in a potent, political rap number called Famine: "I see the
- Irish/ As a race like a child/ that got bashed in the face."
- In addition to these harsh tracks, however, Universal Mother
- does have many gentle moments, including a delicate acoustic
- version of the late grunge rocker Kurt Cobain's composition
- All Apologies.
- </p>
- <p> The music on Keineg's debut album, O Seasons O Castles, is folksy
- and hypnotic, the lyrics both heartfelt and cerebral. The title
- is from an Arthur Rimbaud poem that reads, "O Seasons, O Castles/
- What soul is without sin!" Several songs on the CD explore sin,
- including Franklin, which is about a woman breaking away from
- an abusive partner. "I'm going to find me a good man who don't
- drink/ who don't shout/ who don't throw my prized possessions
- about," sings Keineg, who has a throaty alto with just a touch
- of mysterious smokiness. Not all her songs work, but the ones
- that do, such as Hestia (titled for the goddess of domestic
- activity), have an engaging, combative truthfulness. Keineg
- says she tries to lose herself in her music: "One of the best
- moments in all of life is when time just stops and you are beside
- yourself. I live for that moment."
- </p>
- <p> All three singers strive to connect themselves to old, grand
- traditions. They use Celtic imagery, and Keineg sings one song,
- the stately O Iesu Mawr, in Gaelic; O'Connor quotes William
- Butler Yeats on the liner notes of her CD, and O'Riordan pays
- him tribute in the song Yeats' Grave. This awareness of a particular
- past helps distinguish their songs from the typical rootless
- algae of pop music. In his poem A Coat, Yeats wrote, "I made
- my song a coat/ Covered with embroideries/ Out of old mythologies/
- From heel to throat." As modern women conscious of an Irish
- heritage, O'Riordan, O'Connor and Keineg are creating pop music
- that's stirring and new and also beautifully traditional. They
- wear their coats well.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-